Welp, turns out I loved this book. As a reminder, this was a book I purposely didn’t read because I was scared it wouldn’t live up to the hype in my brain. As it turns out, I didn’t have to worry about that at all! This is such a fun, creepy, atmospheric read! I do wish the shelves had waited to give me this until closer to spooky season, but that’s a minor complaint. I freaking love the beautiful illustrations included in the book. They really made this such an immersive read. The characters and setting were perfection. It very much reminded me of being a kid watching Are You Afraid of the Dark, and that eerie feeling left after they pour the water out onto the campfire and all that’s left is smoke.